Merge pull request 'Fence writers and recover stale Binance WebSockets' (#1) from fix/websocket-failover into master

Reviewed-on: #1

.gitea/workflows/build.yml

@@ -16,13 +16,8 @@ jobs:
     steps:
       - uses: actions/checkout@v4
 
-      - name: Test
-        run: |
-          docker run --rm \
-            -v "$PWD:/app" \
-            -w /app \
-            clojure:temurin-21-tools-deps-alpine \
-            clj -M:test
+      - name: Unit and PostgreSQL fencing tests
+        run: bash scripts/test-fencing.sh
 
       - name: Generate immutable tags
         id: tags

.gitea/workflows/pr.yml

@@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
+name: pr
+on:
+  pull_request:
+    branches: [master]
+jobs:
+  test:
+    runs-on: ubuntu-latest
+    steps:
+      - uses: actions/checkout@v4
+        with:
+          persist-credentials: false
+      - name: Unit and PostgreSQL fencing tests
+        run: bash scripts/test-fencing.sh
+# No registry, deployment, or production credentials in PR jobs.

btcdata-deploy.md

@@ -1,5 +1,32 @@
 # btcdata Kubernetes deployment plan
 
+## 2026-09-19 status and proposed recovery
+
+Kubernetes deployment already exists: one `Recreate` replica on citadel, eligible
+on citadel and srv1893094. Both nodes were Ready. At 14:03 UTC the live price
+WebSocket upgraded successfully but returned data last recorded at 08:36:42 UTC.
+Harbor was refusing connections and Flux apps reconciliation was dependency-blocked.
+No production restart or relocation was performed during this investigation.
+
+The `fix/websocket-failover` application change proposes bounded Binance reconnects,
+60-second in-memory freshness readiness, and PostgreSQL single-writer fencing.
+Every application query uses the session holding advisory lock `728194106`; loss
+of that session cannot cause writes through another pooled connection. Competing
+instances fail startup rather than becoming simultaneous writers. This requires
+all writers to run the fenced version; legacy deployments must stay stopped.
+
+Companion deployment changes in `magnus/deploy` add a **suspended** watchdog:
+three failed minute checks after startup grace request relocation to the other
+healthy node, with a ten-minute cooldown. See `apps/btcdata/FAILOVER.md` in that
+repository for review gates, acceptance tests, limitations, and rollback. This is
+proposed code, not a claim that automatic failover is enabled in production.
+
+Run `make test` for unit tests. Run `bash scripts/test-fencing.sh` for unit tests
+plus PostgreSQL lock-contention, session-loss, and pooled-lock-release tests in
+isolated disposable containers. No production credentials are required.
+
+The remaining sections below are the original migration plan, not current status.
+
 ## Goal and interpretation
 
 Deploy `btcdata` through the existing Flux-managed two-node k3s cluster (`srv1893094` and `citadel`), with **exactly one btcdata pod running at a time**. The pod may run on either node and Kubernetes may recreate it on the other node after failure.

resources/system.edn

@@ -43,36 +43,41 @@
   :db               {:datasource #ig/ref :db.sql/connection}
   :migrate-on-init? true}
 
+ :writer/query-fn
+ {:conn #ig/ref :db.sql/connection
+  :query-fn #ig/ref :db.sql/query-fn
+  :migrations #ig/ref :db.sql/migrations}
+
  :reitit.routes/api
  {:base-path    "/api"
-  :query-fn     #ig/ref :db.sql/query-fn
+  :query-fn     #ig/ref :writer/query-fn
   :binance      #ig/ref :ws/binance
   :frankfurter  #ig/ref :frankfurter/rates
   :strike       #ig/ref :strike/ticker}
 
  :ws/binance
- {:query-fn #ig/ref :db.sql/query-fn
+ {:query-fn #ig/ref :writer/query-fn
   :uri      "wss://stream.binance.com:9443/ws/btcusdt@trade"
   :enabled? #or [#env BINANCE_ENABLED "true"]}
 
  :kraken/ohlc
- {:query-fn #ig/ref :db.sql/query-fn
+ {:query-fn #ig/ref :writer/query-fn
   :enabled? #or [#env KRAKEN_ENABLED "true"]}
 
  :kraken/ohlc-day
- {:query-fn #ig/ref :db.sql/query-fn
+ {:query-fn #ig/ref :writer/query-fn
   :enabled? #or [#env KRAKEN_ENABLED "true"]}
 
  :kraken/ohlc-minute
- {:query-fn #ig/ref :db.sql/query-fn
+ {:query-fn #ig/ref :writer/query-fn
   :enabled? #or [#env KRAKEN_ENABLED "true"]}
 
  :frankfurter/rates
  {:url      #or [#env FRANKFURTER_URL "http://localhost:8080"]
-  :query-fn #ig/ref :db.sql/query-fn}
+  :query-fn #ig/ref :writer/query-fn}
 
  :strike/ticker
- {:query-fn        #ig/ref :db.sql/query-fn
+ {:query-fn        #ig/ref :writer/query-fn
   :api-key         #env STRIKE_API_KEY
   :sats-eur-amount #or [#env SATS_EUR_AMOUNT "55"]
   :enabled?        #or [#env STRIKE_ENABLED "true"]}}

scripts/test-fencing.sh

@@ -0,0 +1,32 @@
+#!/usr/bin/env bash
+# Disposable isolated PostgreSQL; no production credentials or published ports.
+set -euo pipefail
+name="btcdata-test-${GITHUB_RUN_ID:-$$}-${GITHUB_RUN_ATTEMPT:-1}"
+cleanup() {
+  docker rm -f "${name}-runner" "$name" >/dev/null 2>&1 || true
+  docker network rm "$name" >/dev/null 2>&1 || true
+}
+trap cleanup EXIT
+docker network create "$name" >/dev/null
+docker run -d --name "$name" --network "$name" \
+  -e POSTGRES_HOST_AUTH_METHOD=trust postgres:16-alpine >/dev/null
+ready=false
+for _ in $(seq 1 60); do
+  if docker exec "$name" pg_isready -U postgres >/dev/null 2>&1; then
+    ready=true
+    break
+  fi
+  sleep 1
+done
+if [ "$ready" != true ]; then
+  echo 'Disposable PostgreSQL did not become ready' >&2
+  exit 1
+fi
+# The CI workspace is inside the runner container, not on the Docker host.
+# Copy only test inputs; never mount a nonexistent host workspace or copy .env/.git.
+docker create --name "${name}-runner" --network "$name" -w /app \
+  -e "BTCDATA_TEST_JDBC_URL=jdbc:postgresql://$name:5432/postgres?user=postgres" \
+  clojure:temurin-21-tools-deps-alpine clj -M:test >/dev/null
+COPYFILE_DISABLE=1 tar --no-xattrs -cf - deps.edn src resources test env/test | docker cp - "${name}-runner:/app"
+docker start --attach "${name}-runner"
+exit "$(docker inspect --format '{{.State.ExitCode}}' "${name}-runner")"

src/clj/pmagnus/btcdata/core.clj

@@ -16,6 +16,7 @@
    [pmagnus.btcdata.web.routes.api]
    ;; WebSocket clients
    [pmagnus.btcdata.ws.binance]
+   [pmagnus.btcdata.writer]
    ;; Pollers
    [pmagnus.btcdata.kraken.ohlc]
    [pmagnus.btcdata.kraken.ohlc-daily]

src/clj/pmagnus/btcdata/web/controllers/health.clj

@@ -1,7 +1,8 @@
 (ns pmagnus.btcdata.web.controllers.health
   (:require
    [clojure.tools.logging :as log]
-   [ring.util.http-response :as response])
+   [ring.util.http-response :as response]
+   [pmagnus.btcdata.ws.binance :as binance])
   (:import
    [java.lang.management ManagementFactory]))
 
@@ -12,11 +13,13 @@
     :app     {:status "up"}}))
 
 (defn readiness-check!
-  "Report readiness only while the application can query PostgreSQL."
-  [query-fn _req]
+  "Require the lock-owning database session and a fresh upstream stream."
+  [query-fn component _req]
   (try
     (query-fn :check-database {})
-    (response/ok {:status "ready"})
+    (if (binance/fresh? component)
+      (response/ok {:status "ready"})
+      (response/service-unavailable {:status "not ready" :reason "binance stale"}))
     (catch Exception e
       (log/warn e "Database readiness check failed")
       (response/service-unavailable {:status "not ready"}))))

src/clj/pmagnus/btcdata/web/routes/api.clj

@@ -181,7 +181,7 @@
    ["/health"
     {:get health/healthcheck!}]
    ["/ready"
-    {:get (fn [req] (health/readiness-check! (:query-fn opts) req))}]
+    {:get (fn [req] (health/readiness-check! (:query-fn opts) (:binance opts) req))}]
    ["/price/ws"
     {:get        (fn [req] (ws-price-handler opts req))
      :no-doc     true

src/clj/pmagnus/btcdata/writer.clj

@@ -0,0 +1,36 @@
+(ns pmagnus.btcdata.writer
+  "Fence all application queries with one PostgreSQL session advisory lock.
+   Queries use the lock-owning connection itself: a lost session cannot keep
+   writing through a different pooled connection. Never reconnect this session."
+  (:require [integrant.core :as ig]
+            [next.jdbc :as jdbc]))
+
+(def lock-id 728194106)
+
+(defn guarded-query [connection query-fn]
+  (fn [query params]
+    (locking connection
+      (query-fn connection query params))))
+
+(defmethod ig/init-key :writer/query-fn
+  [_ {:keys [conn query-fn]}]
+  (let [connection (jdbc/get-connection conn)]
+    (try
+      ;; Bound lock/query stalls; a failed session is never replaced behind the fence.
+      (.setNetworkTimeout connection
+        (reify java.util.concurrent.Executor (execute [_ task] (.run ^Runnable task)))
+        10000)
+      (when-not (:locked (jdbc/execute-one! connection
+                           ["select pg_try_advisory_lock(?) as locked" lock-id]))
+        (throw (ex-info "Another btcdata writer holds the database lock" {})))
+      (with-meta (guarded-query connection query-fn) {:connection connection})
+      (catch Exception e
+        (.close connection)
+        (throw e)))))
+
+(defmethod ig/halt-key! :writer/query-fn [_ query-fn]
+  (let [connection (:connection (meta query-fn))]
+    (locking connection
+      (try
+        (jdbc/execute-one! connection ["select pg_advisory_unlock(?)" lock-id])
+        (finally (.close connection))))))

src/clj/pmagnus/btcdata/ws/binance.clj

@@ -1,97 +1,102 @@
-(ns pmagnus.btcdata.ws.binance
-  (:require
-   [clojure.data.json :as json]
-   [clojure.tools.logging :as log]
-   [integrant.core :as ig])
-  (:import
-   [java.net URI]
-   [java.net.http HttpClient WebSocket WebSocket$Listener]
-   [java.util.concurrent CompletableFuture CompletionStage]))
-
-(defn- save-price! [query-fn price]
-  (try
-    (query-fn :insert-binance-price! {:price price})
-    (catch Exception e
-      (log/error e "Failed to save BTC price"))))
-
-(defn- connect!
-  "Opens a WebSocket to Binance trade stream and returns the WebSocket instance.
-   `state` is an atom with keys :running?, :last-write, :buffer.
-   `latest-price` is an atom reset with each throttled price for SSE consumers."
-  [uri query-fn state latest-price]
-  (let [client   (HttpClient/newHttpClient)
-        listener (reify WebSocket$Listener
-                   (onOpen [_ ws]
-                     (log/info "Binance WebSocket connected")
-                     (.request ws 1))
-
-                   (onText [_ ws data last?]
-                     (let [buf (:buffer @state)]
-                       (.append buf data)
-                       (when last?
-                         (let [text (str buf)]
-                           (.setLength buf 0)
-                           (try
-                             (let [msg   (json/read-str text :key-fn keyword)
-                                   price (some-> (:p msg) bigdec)]
-                               (when price
-                                 (let [now (System/currentTimeMillis)]
-                                   (when (> (- now (:last-write @state)) 5000)
-                                     (swap! state assoc :last-write now)
-                                     (log/info "BTC price:" (str price))
-                                     (save-price! query-fn price)
-                                     (let [prev-price (:price @latest-price)]
-                                       (reset! latest-price
-                                               {:price      price
-                                                :prev-price prev-price
-                                                :recorded-at (java.time.Instant/now)}))))))
-                             (catch Exception e
-                               (log/error e "Failed to parse Binance message")))))
-                       (let [^CompletionStage cf (CompletableFuture/completedFuture nil)]
-                         (.request ws 1)
-                         cf)))
-
-                   (onClose [_ _ws code reason]
-                     (log/warn "Binance WebSocket closed:" code reason)
-                     (when (:running? @state)
-                       (future
-                         (Thread/sleep 3000)
-                         (when (:running? @state)
-                           (log/info "Reconnecting to Binance...")
-                           (try
-                             (let [ws (connect! uri query-fn state latest-price)]
-                               (swap! state assoc :ws ws))
-                             (catch Exception e
-                               (log/error e "Binance reconnect failed")))))))
-
-                   (onError [_ _ws error]
-                     (log/error error "Binance WebSocket error")))]
-    (-> (.newWebSocketBuilder client)
-        (.buildAsync (URI. uri) listener)
-        (.join))))
-
-(defmethod ig/init-key :ws/binance
-  [_ {:keys [query-fn uri enabled?] :or {enabled? "true"}}]
-  (if-not (= enabled? "true")
-    (do (log/info "Binance WebSocket disabled")
-        {:state        (atom {:running? false})
-         :latest-price (atom nil)})
-    (do (log/info "Starting Binance WebSocket listener:" uri)
-        (let [latest-price (atom nil)
-              state        (atom {:running?   true
-                                  :last-write 0
-                                  :buffer     (StringBuilder.)
-                                  :ws         nil})
-              ws           (connect! uri query-fn state latest-price)]
-          (swap! state assoc :ws ws)
-          {:state        state
-           :latest-price latest-price}))))
-
-(defmethod ig/halt-key! :ws/binance
-  [_ {:keys [state]}]
-  (log/info "Stopping Binance WebSocket listener")
-  (swap! state assoc :running? false)
-  (when-let [ws (:ws @state)]
-    (try
-      (.sendClose ws WebSocket/NORMAL_CLOSURE "shutting down")
-      (catch Exception _))))
+(ns pmagnus.btcdata.ws.binance
+  (:require [clojure.data.json :as json]
+            [clojure.tools.logging :as log]
+            [integrant.core :as ig])
+  (:import [java.net URI]
+           [java.net.http HttpClient WebSocket WebSocket$Listener]
+           [java.time Duration Instant]
+           [java.util.concurrent CompletableFuture TimeUnit]))
+
+(def stale-after-ms 60000)
+
+(defn fresh?
+  "Only in-process stream data counts; database fallback is not stream health."
+  ([component] (fresh? component (System/currentTimeMillis)))
+  ([{:keys [state latest-price]} now]
+   (let [{:keys [enabled? connected?]} @state
+         recorded-at (:recorded-at @latest-price)]
+     (or (false? enabled?)
+         (and connected? (some? recorded-at)
+              (<= 0 (- now (.toEpochMilli ^Instant recorded-at)) stale-after-ms))))))
+
+(defn- connect! [client uri query-fn state latest-price generation]
+  (let [buffer (StringBuilder.)
+        current? #(and (:running? @state) (= generation (:generation @state)))
+        listener
+        (reify WebSocket$Listener
+          (onOpen [_ ws]
+            (if (current?)
+              (do (swap! state assoc :connected? true)
+                  (log/info "Binance WebSocket connected")
+                  (.request ws 1))
+              (.abort ws)))
+          (onText [_ ws data last?]
+            (when (current?)
+              (.append buffer data)
+              (when last?
+                (let [text (str buffer)]
+                  (.setLength buffer 0)
+                  (try
+                    (when-let [price (some-> (json/read-str text :key-fn keyword) :p bigdec)]
+                      (let [now (System/currentTimeMillis)]
+                        (swap! state assoc :last-message now)
+                        (when (> (- now (:last-write @state)) 5000)
+                          ;; Publish only after persistence succeeds.
+                          (query-fn :insert-binance-price! {:price price})
+                          (swap! state assoc :last-write now)
+                          (reset! latest-price {:price price
+                                                :prev-price (:price @latest-price)
+                                                :recorded-at (Instant/now)}))))
+                    (catch Exception e
+                      (log/error e "Failed to process Binance price"))))))
+            (.request ws 1)
+            (CompletableFuture/completedFuture nil))
+          (onClose [_ _ code reason]
+            (when (current?)
+              (swap! state assoc :connected? false)
+              (log/warn "Binance WebSocket closed:" code reason))
+            (CompletableFuture/completedFuture nil))
+          (onError [_ _ error]
+            (when (current?)
+              (swap! state assoc :connected? false)
+              (log/warn error "Binance WebSocket error"))))]
+    (-> (.newWebSocketBuilder ^HttpClient client)
+        (.connectTimeout (Duration/ofSeconds 10))
+        (.buildAsync (URI. uri) listener)
+        (.get 15 TimeUnit/SECONDS))))
+
+(defmethod ig/init-key :ws/binance
+  [_ {:keys [query-fn uri enabled?] :or {enabled? "true"}}]
+  (let [enabled (= enabled? "true")
+        latest-price (atom nil)
+        state (atom {:enabled? enabled :running? enabled :connected? false
+                     :last-write 0 :last-message 0 :generation nil :ws nil})
+        client (when enabled (-> (HttpClient/newBuilder)
+                                 (.connectTimeout (Duration/ofSeconds 10)) .build))
+        worker
+        (when enabled
+          (future
+            (try
+              (while (:running? @state)
+                (let [generation (Object.)]
+                  (swap! state assoc :generation generation :connected? false
+                         :last-message (System/currentTimeMillis))
+                  (try
+                    (let [ws (connect! client uri query-fn state latest-price generation)]
+                      (swap! state assoc :ws ws)
+                      (try
+                        (while (and (:running? @state) (:connected? @state)
+                                    (< (- (System/currentTimeMillis) (:last-message @state)) stale-after-ms))
+                          (Thread/sleep 1000))
+                        (finally (.abort ^WebSocket ws))))
+                    (catch InterruptedException e (throw e))
+                    (catch Exception e (log/warn e "Binance connection failed; retrying"))
+                    (finally (swap! state assoc :connected? false :generation nil :ws nil))))
+                (when (:running? @state) (Thread/sleep 3000)))
+              (catch InterruptedException _))))]
+    {:state state :latest-price latest-price :worker worker}))
+
+(defmethod ig/halt-key! :ws/binance [_ {:keys [state worker]}]
+  (swap! state assoc :running? false :connected? false :generation nil)
+  (when-let [ws (:ws @state)] (.abort ^WebSocket ws))
+  (when worker (future-cancel worker)))

test/clj/pmagnus/btcdata/web/controllers/health_test.clj

@@ -1,26 +1,24 @@
 (ns pmagnus.btcdata.web.controllers.health-test
-  (:require
-   [clojure.test :refer [deftest is testing]]
-   [pmagnus.btcdata.web.controllers.health :as health]))
+  (:require [clojure.test :refer [deftest is]]
+            [pmagnus.btcdata.web.controllers.health :as health]))
+
+(def disabled-stream {:state (atom {:enabled? false}) :latest-price (atom nil)})
 
 (deftest healthcheck-is-process-only
-  (let [response (health/healthcheck! {})]
-    (is (= 200 (:status response)))
-    (is (= "up" (get-in response [:body :app :status])))))
+  (is (= 200 (:status (health/healthcheck! {})))))
 
 (deftest readiness-check-tests-database
-  (testing "ready when the database query succeeds"
-    (let [called   (atom nil)
-          query-fn (fn [query params]
-                     (reset! called [query params])
-                     {:healthy 1})
-          response (health/readiness-check! query-fn {})]
-      (is (= 200 (:status response)))
-      (is (= {:status "ready"} (:body response)))
-      (is (= [:check-database {}] @called))))
+  (let [called (atom nil)
+        query-fn (fn [query params] (reset! called [query params]))]
+    (is (= 200 (:status (health/readiness-check! query-fn disabled-stream {}))))
+    (is (= [:check-database {}] @called)))
+  (is (= 503 (:status (health/readiness-check!
+                       (fn [_ _] (throw (ex-info "database unavailable" {})))
+                       disabled-stream {})))))
 
-  (testing "not ready when the database query fails"
-    (let [query-fn (fn [_ _] (throw (ex-info "database unavailable" {})))
-          response (health/readiness-check! query-fn {})]
-      (is (= 503 (:status response)))
-      (is (= {:status "not ready"} (:body response))))))
+(deftest stale-stream-is-not-ready
+  (is (= 503 (:status (health/readiness-check!
+                       (fn [_ _] {})
+                       {:state (atom {:enabled? true :connected? true})
+                        :latest-price (atom {:recorded-at java.time.Instant/EPOCH})}
+                       {})))))

test/clj/pmagnus/btcdata/writer_test.clj

@@ -0,0 +1,52 @@
+(ns pmagnus.btcdata.writer-test
+  (:require [clojure.test :refer [deftest is]]
+            [integrant.core :as ig]
+            [conman.core :as conman]
+            [next.jdbc :as jdbc]
+            [pmagnus.btcdata.writer :as writer]))
+
+(deftest queries-use-lock-session
+  (let [connection (Object.)
+        seen (atom nil)
+        query (writer/guarded-query connection
+                (fn [& args] (reset! seen args) :result))]
+    (is (= :result (query :insert-price {:price 1})))
+    (is (= [connection :insert-price {:price 1}] @seen))))
+
+(deftest postgres-session-fencing
+  ;; Optional disposable PostgreSQL integration test; never use production here.
+  (if-let [url (System/getenv "BTCDATA_TEST_JDBC_URL")]
+    (let [ds (jdbc/get-datasource {:jdbcUrl url})
+          opts {:conn ds :query-fn (fn [conn _ _]
+                                    (jdbc/execute-one! conn ["select 1 as healthy"]))}
+          first-writer (ig/init-key :writer/query-fn opts)]
+      (try
+        (is (= 1 (:healthy (first-writer :check {}))))
+        (is (thrown-with-msg? clojure.lang.ExceptionInfo #"Another btcdata writer"
+              (ig/init-key :writer/query-fn opts)))
+        ;; Closing the owning session cannot transparently reconnect for writes.
+        (.close (:connection (meta first-writer)))
+        (is (thrown? Exception (first-writer :check {})))
+        (let [replacement (ig/init-key :writer/query-fn opts)]
+          (try
+            (is (= 1 (:healthy (replacement :check {}))))
+            (finally (ig/halt-key! :writer/query-fn replacement))))
+        (finally
+          (when-not (.isClosed (:connection (meta first-writer)))
+            (ig/halt-key! :writer/query-fn first-writer)))))
+    (println "SKIP PostgreSQL fencing integration: set BTCDATA_TEST_JDBC_URL")))
+
+(deftest pooled-session-releases-lock-on-halt
+  (when-let [url (System/getenv "BTCDATA_TEST_JDBC_URL")]
+    (let [pool (conman/connect! {:jdbc-url url :maximum-pool-size 3})
+          opts {:conn pool :query-fn (fn [_ _ _] :ok)}]
+      (try
+        (let [leader (ig/init-key :writer/query-fn opts)]
+          (is (thrown? Exception (ig/init-key :writer/query-fn opts)))
+          (ig/halt-key! :writer/query-fn leader))
+        ;; An independent connection can acquire after pooled-session shutdown.
+        (let [other-opts (assoc opts :conn (jdbc/get-datasource {:jdbcUrl url}))
+              leader (ig/init-key :writer/query-fn other-opts)]
+          (is (= :ok (leader :check {})))
+          (ig/halt-key! :writer/query-fn leader))
+        (finally (conman/disconnect! pool))))))

test/clj/pmagnus/btcdata/ws/binance_test.clj

@@ -0,0 +1,41 @@
+(ns pmagnus.btcdata.ws.binance-test
+  (:require [clojure.test :refer [deftest is]]
+            [integrant.core :as ig]
+            [pmagnus.btcdata.ws.binance :as binance])
+  (:import [java.time Instant]))
+
+(deftest freshness-boundaries
+  (let [state (atom {:enabled? true :connected? true})
+        price (atom {:recorded-at (Instant/ofEpochMilli 100000)})
+        component {:state state :latest-price price}]
+    (is (binance/fresh? component 100000))
+    (is (binance/fresh? component 160000))
+    (is (not (binance/fresh? component 160001)))
+    (is (not (binance/fresh? component 99999)))
+    (swap! state assoc :connected? false)
+    (is (not (binance/fresh? component 100000)))
+    (reset! price nil)
+    (is (not (binance/fresh? component 100000)))))
+
+(deftest disabled-stream-does-not-connect
+  (let [component (ig/init-key :ws/binance {:enabled? "false" :uri "invalid"})]
+    (is (binance/fresh? component))
+    (is (nil? (:worker component)))
+    (ig/halt-key! :ws/binance component)
+    (is (false? (:running? @(:state component))))))
+
+(deftest initial-failure-is-retried-and-worker-stops
+  (let [attempts (atom 0)
+        connect-var (ns-resolve 'pmagnus.btcdata.ws.binance 'connect!)]
+    (with-redefs-fn
+      {connect-var (fn [& _] (swap! attempts inc) (throw (ex-info "test failure" {})))}
+      (fn []
+        (let [component (ig/init-key :ws/binance {:enabled? "true" :uri "test"})]
+          (try
+            (let [deadline (+ (System/currentTimeMillis) 6000)]
+              (while (and (< @attempts 2) (< (System/currentTimeMillis) deadline))
+                (Thread/sleep 20)))
+            (is (>= @attempts 2))
+            (is (not (binance/fresh? component)))
+            (finally (ig/halt-key! :ws/binance component)))
+          (is (future-cancelled? (:worker component))))))))